Fair Haven, New York cabins and vacation rentals

Share this town page

10 vacation rental(s) near here

Cottage 9

Anchor Resort & Marina

Cottage 9

Fair Haven NY

  • 1 - bedrooms,
  • 1 - bathrooms,
  • sleeps - 4
  • Pets considered
  • $130 - $155 night
  • $800 - $925 week

Unit #9 is a true lakefront vacation, with the shoreline just a few steps from the front door. This RV rental unit is 38...

CABIN DETAILS. Rent direct - no booking website fees. »

Cottage 1

Anchor Resort & Marina

Cottage 1

Fair Haven NY

  • 2 - bedrooms,
  • 1 - bathrooms,
  • sleeps - 4
  • Pets considered
  • $135 - $155 night
  • $820 - $955 week

When it comes to relaxing in the sun, having fun tubing or water skiing, or testing your fishing skills; Cottage 1 at th...

CABIN DETAILS. Rent direct - no booking website fees. »

Main House

Anchor Resort & Marina

Main House

Fair Haven NY

  • 4 - bedrooms,
  • 3 - bathrooms,
  • sleeps - 12
  • Sorry, no pets
  • $225 - $225 night
  • $1200 - $1350 week

Guests love our 1860’s brick Victorian home - lots of original wood work that has been restored and pine hardwood floo...

CABIN DETAILS. Rent direct - no booking website fees. »

Cottage 3

Anchor Resort & Marina

Cottage 3

Fair Haven NY

  • 2 - bedrooms,
  • 1 - bathrooms,
  • sleeps - 4
  • Pets considered
  • $135 - $150 night
  • $820 - $925 week

Anchor Resort Cottage 3 is brand new construction with two bedrooms, 1 bath, a kitchenette with microwave, and a sparkli...

CABIN DETAILS. Rent direct - no booking website fees. »

Cottage 4

Anchor Resort & Marina

Cottage 4

Fair Haven NY

  • 2 - bedrooms,
  • 1 - bathrooms,
  • sleeps - 4
  • Pets considered
  • $130 - $150 night
  • $800 - $925 week

Looking for a New York Lake Ontario cabin and a Great Lakes experience? You’ll have the southern shore of Lake Ontario...

CABIN DETAILS. Rent direct - no booking website fees. »

Cottage 8

Anchor Resort & Marina

Cottage 8

Fair Haven NY

  • 3 - bedrooms,
  • 2 - bathrooms,
  • sleeps - 6
  • Pets considered
  • $185 - $200 night
  • $1100 - $1250 week

The front porch of this 3-bedroom/2-bath modular Lake Ontario vacation cottage has pleasing views of Little Sodus Bay. T...

CABIN DETAILS. Rent direct - no booking website fees. »

Cottage 7

Anchor Resort & Marina

Cottage 7

Fair Haven NY

  • 3 - bedrooms,
  • 2 - bathrooms,
  • sleeps - 6
  • Pets considered
  • $185 - $200 night
  • $1100 - $1250 week

Anchor Resort and Marina waterfront cottages are family-friendly and surrounded by stretching lawns and mature trees, wi...

CABIN DETAILS. Rent direct - no booking website fees. »

Cottage 5

Anchor Resort & Marina

Cottage 5

Fair Haven NY

  • 3 - bedrooms,
  • 2 - bathrooms,
  • sleeps - 6
  • Pets considered
  • $165 - $180 night
  • $1025 - $11250 week

Unwind and take in the picturesque views of Lake Ontario’s Little Sodus Bay from Anchor Resort’s Cottage 5. The 3-be...

CABIN DETAILS. Rent direct - no booking website fees. »

Cottage 6

Anchor Resort & Marina

Cottage 6

Fair Haven NY

  • 3 - bedrooms,
  • 2 - bathrooms,
  • sleeps - 6
  • Pets considered
  • $165 - $180 night
  • $1025 - $1125 week

Anchor Resort Cottage 6 is a 3-bedroom/2-bath updated, doublewide modular vacation home on the shores of Lake Ontario. Y...

CABIN DETAILS. Rent direct - no booking website fees. »

Cottage 2

Anchor Resort & Marina

Cottage 2

Fair Haven NY

  • 2 - bedrooms,
  • 1 - bathrooms,
  • sleeps - 4
  • Pets considered
  • $135 - $155 night
  • $820 - $955 week

Ready to live the lake life for a long weekend, or better yet a full week? Our newer Cottage 2 in upstate New york is re...

CABIN DETAILS. Rent direct - no booking website fees. »

Inquire and book directly with owners/managers.

Select your favorite properties above. Send one inquiry form to multiple rental owners.

(Give rental owners/managers a few details about your getaway.)
Click Send Inquiry button 1 time

Sign Up for NY Vacation Rental Specials

Monthly newsletter includes other surprises.