Compare these Fair Haven NY cottages on Sodus Bay!

Fair Haven, New York cabins and vacation rentals

Share this NY town page

10 vacation rental(s) near this location...

Main House

Anchor Resort & Marina

Main House

Fair Haven, NY

BOOK DIRECT
$225 - $240 per night
$1250 - $1400 per week
3rd party booking
$292.5 - $312 per night
$1625 - $1820 per week

Guests love our 1860’s brick Victorian home - lots of original wood work that has been restored and pine hardwood floo...

VIEW DETAILS and rent direct. No booking website fees. »

Cottage 7

Anchor Resort & Marina

Cottage 7

Fair Haven, NY

Pets considered

BOOK DIRECT
$185 - $210 per night
$1100 - $1275 per week
3rd party booking
$240.5 - $273 per night
$1430 - $1657.5 per week

Anchor Resort and Marina waterfront cottages are family-friendly and surrounded by stretching lawns and mature trees, wi...

VIEW DETAILS and rent direct. No booking website fees. »

Cottage 5

Anchor Resort & Marina

Cottage 5

Fair Haven, NY

Pets considered

BOOK DIRECT
$165 - $185 per night
$1050 - $1150 per week
3rd party booking
$214.5 - $240.5 per night
$1365 - $1495 per week

Unwind and take in the picturesque views of Lake Ontario’s Little Sodus Bay from Anchor Resort’s Cottage 5. The 3-be...

VIEW DETAILS and rent direct. No booking website fees. »

Cottage 1

Anchor Resort & Marina

Cottage 1

Fair Haven, NY

Pets considered

BOOK DIRECT
$140 - $160 per night
$820 - $960 per week
3rd party booking
$182 - $208 per night
$1066 - $1248 per week

When it comes to relaxing in the sun, having fun tubing or water skiing, or testing your fishing skills; Cottage 1 at th...

VIEW DETAILS and rent direct. No booking website fees. »

Cottage 4

Anchor Resort & Marina

Cottage 4

Fair Haven, NY

Pets considered

BOOK DIRECT
$135 - $150 per night
$800 - $930 per week
3rd party booking
$175.5 - $195 per night
$1040 - $1209 per week

Looking for a New York Lake Ontario cabin and a Great Lakes experience? You’ll have the southern shore of Lake Ontario...

VIEW DETAILS and rent direct. No booking website fees. »

Cottage 2

Anchor Resort & Marina

Cottage 2

Fair Haven, NY

Pets considered

BOOK DIRECT
$140 - $160 per night
$820 - $960 per week
3rd party booking
$182 - $208 per night
$1066 - $1248 per week

Ready to live the lake life for a long weekend, or better yet a full week? Our newer Cottage 2 in upstate New york is re...

VIEW DETAILS and rent direct. No booking website fees. »

Cottage 9

Anchor Resort & Marina

Cottage 9

Fair Haven, NY

Pets considered

BOOK DIRECT
$135 - $160 per night
$800 - $930 per week
3rd party booking
$175.5 - $208 per night
$1040 - $1209 per week

Unit #9 is a true lakefront vacation, with the shoreline just a few steps from the front door. This RV rental unit is 38...

VIEW DETAILS and rent direct. No booking website fees. »

Cottage 8

Anchor Resort & Marina

Cottage 8

Fair Haven, NY

Pets considered

BOOK DIRECT
$190 - $210 per night
$1100 - $1275 per week
3rd party booking
$247 - $273 per night
$1430 - $1657.5 per week

The front porch of this 3-bedroom/2-bath modular Lake Ontario vacation cottage has pleasing views of Little Sodus Bay. T...

VIEW DETAILS and rent direct. No booking website fees. »

Cottage 3

Anchor Resort & Marina

Cottage 3

Fair Haven, NY

Pets considered

BOOK DIRECT
$140 - $160 per night
$820 - $960 per week
3rd party booking
$182 - $208 per night
$1066 - $1248 per week

Anchor Resort Cottage 3 is brand new construction with two bedrooms, 1 bath, a kitchenette with microwave, and a sparkli...

VIEW DETAILS and rent direct. No booking website fees. »

Cottage 6

Anchor Resort & Marina

Cottage 6

Fair Haven, NY

BOOK DIRECT
$165 - $185 per night
$1050 - $1150 per week
3rd party booking
$214.5 - $240.5 per night
$1365 - $1495 per week

Anchor Resort Cottage 6 is a 3-bedroom/2-bath updated, doublewide modular vacation home on the shores of Lake Ontario. Y...

VIEW DETAILS and rent direct. No booking website fees. »

Sign Up for Vacation Rental Specials

Monthly newsletter and other surprises.